'Change' Discovery Studies

Aboriginal Discussion

Home
A Broiler Chickens Life Cycle
Changes To my Local Community
Martin Luthers Revolution
Habits of Mind
I never told anyone that I was a cannibal
Impact of Change in Australia
Impulsivity
Impulsivity
Contract
Merchant of Venice - Scene 1
Middle Age Artwork
Perspective Sketches
Deadly Unna
Renaissance Inventions
Renaissance Map
Types of Australian Changes
Aboriginal Discussion
Christian Values
Renaissance Composers and Instruments
Change of Daily lives
Changes to the Aboriginal Community
Create a Device
Persistence
Explaining Speed to a Martian

A debate took place between two classes on Aboriginal Issues. Here are my views on a few of these topics.

Discussion: Aboriginals

 

Why should this generation of Aboriginals still be angry about what happened so long ago (the claiming of Australia by the British).

 

We did not do it…so should we say sorry?

 

Story of the Aboriginal who tried to burn a tree; your views on the story.

2. This generation of Aboriginal Australians consist of mainly the first or second generations after those that were killed. Most would not have ever seen their grandparents. There are even those whose parents were killed when they were very young, This was the work of the white English invaders who claimed the land as their own.

 

In the time of Captain Cook, Australia was proclaimed ‘Terra Nullus’. They believed that no one owned Australia and there was freedom to claim it. When Captain Cook arrived, he resorted to mass killing the original inhabitants. This was cruel and unfair, aswell as a terrible thing to do. But should the aboriginals be so possessive towards this land?

 

This may be where they have lived for centuries, but it is not a matter of who got there first. We all have a right to live here. Even the aboriginals were not first born here. Thousands of years ago when humanity first appeared, we were all in Africa. And so, everyone has the right to live everywhere else. The colour of our skin or background should not determine who gets to live where.

 

Much of the Aboriginal culture was forbidden by the English. They thought of them as less important. The most probable reason for why the Aboriginals are so upset is that throughout their known history, they were never invaded. Since Australia is an island, they never experienced the threat of invasion, and are unused to territory wars. Most countries are surrounded by others and they would often be at war. The native Aboriginals were caught unprepared. The uncompassionate way to see it is that are crying over spilt milk

 

There is much debate over whether the Australian government need or should say sorry to the Aboriginals. John Howard, who is currently out prime minister, was once a lawyer. He fought against apologising. The side he took may portray his views; however, lawyers fight for their client, regardless of whether they are right or wrong. We have not yet apologised to the Aboriginals for claiming their land without any legal agreement

 

Australia is a amazingly culturally diverse nation. There are a greater number of other nationality immigrants or descendants of such who did not originate in England. By apologising, most of us would be speaking sorrow for what we had no part in. Even those whose ancestors were of the English land claimers, were not the ones who took the lands themselves. We would be saying ‘sorry’ for what we have not done.

 

On the other hand, you can interpret ‘sorry’ in the form that you are sad that their culture was disrupted. If you take it this way, most people would apologise on the spot. It is not a matter of wishing to apologise, but the problem of interpretation

 

The discussion of apologising is caught in a misunderstanding. It would be beneficial if an Aboriginal leader were to announce his people’s wants. It is probably best that the government apologise to the Aboriginals, whether or not they mean it. This will definitely ease some tension.

  

 

aboriginal.gif
The colours of the Flag: The red represents the earth, the black representing the Aboriginals and the yellow circle representing the sun

Aboriginal Flag

 This flasg was adopted as the symbol of Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Island people when it was first flown in 1971

Favorites

1. Aboriginal are commonly thought of  as unthinking and irrational. I have witnessed an attempt by a Australian native to burn down a tree infront of a coffee shop. This was an act of rage, brought on by the attitude of one shop keeper. The shop keeper refused to serve the Aboriginal.

 

You can understand why the aboriginal was upset. His response was a stupid and an   unnecessary thing to do, but this action might have been taken by someone of any race. Simply by seeing one aboriginal burning down a tree, you cannot claim that Aboriginals like to burn things. This incident may be an isolated case. Other aboriginals may have dealt with the situation differently.

 

The shop keepers choice not to serve that person was disgusting. Such an act is racist and should be completely stamped out. The fact that it still goes on after so many years of living in harmony with the natives is unheard of. Aboriginals are our equals. The shop keeper’s and the Aboriginal’s  actions were both wrong.

 

Here's a list of some of my favorite music:

Nirvana, Frank Sinatra, Ibrahim Ferrer